The State That Eliminated Pensions and Wants Them Back

Across the United States, more than 19 million state and local government employees keep our communities running every day. These workers include teachers educating the next generation, firefighters and police officers ensuring public safety, and countless others who maintain the essential services that citizens rely on. For many of these public employees, a secure retirement is possible because they have access to defined benefit pensions.
Public-service careers often come with demanding responsibilities, lower pay than comparable private-sector jobs, and high levels of accountability. Retirement benefits are important to public workers, and pensions are a proven tool to help governments recruit and retain qualified employees by offering long-term financial security in exchange for a career of public service.
Americans consistently express strong support for pensions for public service professionals. NIRS polling shows that the public values providing retirement security to those who educate, protect, and serve our communities. This support is especially strong because public employees themselves contribute from every paycheck into their pensions, demonstrating shared responsibility.
A common misconception is that public pensions are paid primarily with tax dollars. In reality, the vast majority of pension benefits are funded by two sources: employee contributions and investment returns. On average, about 12 percent of pension financing comes directly from employees, 59 percent from long-term investment earnings, and 29 percent from employer (taxpayer) contributions. This structure makes pensions not only secure, but also highly efficient.
While pay may lag in many instances, the public sector tends to offer strong healthcare and retirement benefits. For example, 86 percent of state and local government employees have access to a defined benefit pension plan as compared to only 15 percent in the private sector. And 89 percent of state and local government employees have healthcare benefits through their workplace.
These benefits help the public sector enjoy much higher retention rates of workers from year to year, compared to private employers. These higher retention rates mean more experienced people providing in public services, including schools, public safety and many other services we rely on daily.
of young workers hired into public safety jobs who expected to stay until retirement.
Source: The Role of Defined Benefit Pensions in Recruiting and Retaining Public Safety Professionals
of public workers participating in a state-level teachers retirement plan with more than 10 years on the job in 2024.
National Institute on Retirement Security
of California teachers reach 5 years of service who will eventually work at least 20 years.
National Institute on Retirement Security
The State That Eliminated Pensions and Wants Them Back
The State That Eliminated Pensions and Wants Them Back
Contrary to popular belief that Millennials and Generation Z employees are constantly switching jobs, new research from the National Institute on Retirement Security finds that younger workers today show job retention patterns that closely mirror previous generations at the same stage of their careers.
A research infographic from the National Institute on Retirement Security (NIRS) finds strong support among Americans for retirement benefits provided to state and local government employees. “What Do Americans Think About Pensions For Public Employees? finds 86 percent of Americans say all workers, not just those employed by state and local governments, should have a […]
As state and local governments across the nation continue to struggle filling public safety positions, new research from the National Institute on Retirement Security (NIRS) explores how defined benefit pension plans are a critical workforce management tool for public safety employers. The Role of Defined Benefit Pensions in Recruiting and Retaining Public Safety Professionals examines data from a nationally representative sample of 28 police and fire pension plans, as well as national datasets.